Jax intervention Reasonable Doubt
Emayatzy Corinealdi as Jax Stewart in Season 4 of Hulu’s Reasonable Doubt. Hulu
7 min read

Why Jax Stewart’s addiction arc matters

Reasonable Doubt is forcing viewers to confront a version of addiction they don’t often see onscreen

Hulu’s Reasonable Doubt has sparked a dramatic split among fans. The show’s main character, Jackson “Jax” Stewart, played by actress Emayatzy Corinealdi, is always up for a good fight, yet she now faces her most difficult challenge: opioid addiction.

While some viewers laud the show for finally forcing Jax to confront her demons, others are unhappy with her “turning” into an addict. Out of frustration — or perhaps as a joke — critics of the season’s direction are threatening to pull their support or calling for the show’s cancellation.

Raamla Mohamed Hunter, the show’s creator, is aware of the criticisms. Mohamed told Onyx Collective, “I’ve always thought that Jax was an addict,” and reinforced her stance on Blex Media.

“The whole point is that between the cigarettes, the addiction to work, and the addiction mess in general, I think we’ve already seen that she has addictive qualities,” she said. “And we have her father, who has a history of addiction as well, and it’s important for people to see the genetic role addiction can play.”

It makes sense why fans don’t want to see, or can’t fully acknowledge, Jax being this far gone. She’s relatable and, to some, aspirational. It’s tough watching her struggle through what some might think is a tired trope of addiction, even if this variant has rarely been studied academically or shown on screen.

Studies on Black opioid use and abuse, particularly in Black women, are rare. A 2022 article from the National Library of Medicine acknowledges that Black women have been “left out of the larger conversation” on opioid addiction, and a 2023 article from the University of Pennsylvania’s Leonard Davis Institute of Health Economics noted that the impact of the opioid epidemic on Black women has not been widely studied or discussed.

Mohamed also pointed to Jax’s “compounded trauma” as a catalyst for her addictive behavior. 

In season one, viewers learn her stepfather molested her. In season two, Jax’s husband impregnates another woman, and the baby dies during childbirth. In the third season, Jax forms a close relationship with her client, Ozzie, a child star and substance abuser who’d been molested for years by his manager. By season’s end, Ozzie overdoses in Jax’s home and the woman accused of molesting him shoots Jax twice.

Jax starts season four in a coma. During her recovery, a doctor prescribes pain management pills. She’s initially hesitant but eventually relents. Mohamed says season four gives Jax a chance to “actually have to face her physical pain, [which] is a way to also see if she needs to finally face her emotional pain.”

Jax Stewart intervention Reasonable Doubt
Jax Stewart’s family and friends stage an intervention during Season 4 of Hulu’s Reasonable Doubt.

Hulu

Despite her personal and professional challenges, Jax appeared to have it all: a great family, an impressive career, and a good support network. She doesn’t fit the stereotypical profile or look of a drug abuser. Stephanie Henrique, a licensed clinical social worker with more than 14 years of clinical experience, says the portrayal adds depth to the character.

“We know success, education, financial stability, or professional achievement will not protect someone from addiction, and [Jax] is no exception,” Henrique said. “I appreciate that the show is allowing a Black woman who is accomplished, complex, imperfect, and vulnerable to occupy that space.”

Michelle B. Taylor, PhD., MSW — a retired social worker and substance abuse counselor — highlighted the portrayal while making a larger point about compulsive behavior.

“Being successful and addicted to substances are not mutually exclusive identities,” Taylor said. “[There are] Black women CEOs, high-level administrators, and every Sunday they’re getting bottomless mimosas. Every Thursday and Tuesday they’re at happy hour. [It’s] their way of medicating, disconnecting and dissociating just to cope. That’s binge drinking and indicative of something else [going on].”

Reasonable Doubt’s depiction of addiction has a unique twist. Hollywood isn’t shy about showing Black addicts, but its scope is, generally, limited. The dearth of examples may be affecting fans’ ability to fully understand what Jax is going through. 

On the show, Eric — played by R&B singer Tank — is Jax’s newest client. In Episode 8, Eric believes Jax has lost her edge during his trial and offers her pills to bring it back. During the offer, he calls Jax “Pookie,” harkening back to the junkie Chris Rock popularized in 1991 movie New Jack City. Eric’s demonization of Jax’s substance issues is aligned with the same logic used when calling Jax, a Black woman abusing pills, a “crackhead.”

The lack of nuance is likely tied to the lack of representation for a drug not typically linked with the Black community, which complicates conversations surrounding Jax’s internal strife.  

“[Pills aren’t] commonly associated with Black women, primarily because the health field doesn’t like to give them to Black people, or women,” Taylor said. “Pills [aren’t a] big issue in the community. We’ve got lean. We’ve got heroin. We’ve got crack. But, pills not being our thing? That might be people not fully understanding addiction and how it manifests.”

Fans’ strong objection to Jax’s storyline becomes more fascinating when compared to Kyle Bary’s fan-favorite character, Ozzie. Both characters were molested by someone close to the family during their childhood. They were dependent on pills to manage, in part, the pressures of a high-stress job. Ozzie was the breadwinner for his family. Jax often feels as if everything is reliant on her being at her absolute best. 

The two are so intrinsically linked that it’s a major reason Jax took Ozzie’s case. It’s why Ozzie, in a heartfelt scene featuring him speaking to Jax from beyond the grave, pleading with Jax for her to get help resonated so much for both Jax and the audience. They felt like two people who shared a pain only the other could understand. 

Ozzie’s character felt wholly accepted by the audience, as there were no calls for the show being canceled during his struggles.

That hasn’t been the case for its lead character. 

“The way that the media has depicted addiction, the way the news has covered addiction, the stories we hear in different spaces, they shape how we think about addiction,” Taylor said. “I imagine women who want to be represented in more positive ways, who have seen repeated representations of Black women in addiction, in the alleys, dirty, messed up, or whatever, are bothered that [Jax] is being associated with that [portrayal].

Henrique said what is happening to Jax is more common than people think.

“There are people who are incredibly successful professionally, who are raising children, maintaining relationships, managing households, and meeting every external expectation, but internally they are overwhelmed, disconnected, anxious, grieving, or carrying unresolved trauma,” she said. “People praise you for being strong, dependable, and successful, without recognizing that sometimes those very behaviors are helping you avoid what is happening internally.”

Viewers rejecting the season are missing a positive from placing their favorite character in such a quagmire. Jax’s hardship can serve as an avatar for others in the community struggling with opioids or any other form of addiction. Henrique wants Jax’s story to be a north star.

“You can be strong and still be struggling,” she said. “And you can be the person everyone depends on and still need someone to show up for you.”

Taylor, given some of the audience’s reaction, is doubtful this sole season can change things but believes it’s a net positive when Black women are “shown in their fullness.” She hopes people will challenge themselves to view Jax, and others like her, through a different lens.

“What it might lend to is [more understanding] for people who are living with addiction, people who are battling the devastating effects of substance abuse,” Taylor said. “Perhaps this will create more empathy.”

Garfield Hylton is a professional journalist, ghostwriter and digital storyteller. When he's not writing essays, he's in the gym working on his jumpshot so the young boys don't run him off the court.